Letting-the-dust-gather--Kinect-for-Xbox-360 Letting the dust gather: Kinect for Xbox 360

   18/04/2011 at 07:32       Phil May       11 COMMENTS.
 - Microsoft Kinect, Xbox 360, Room 101, Made of Fail, Bowel Movement

Joe Bennet's excellent series of retrospectives on this very site made me think. With everyone else now jumping on the retrospectives bandwagon, isn't it right and proper to flip the whole idea on its head and consign a few white elephant projects to the dreary cobweb-filled interiors of Room 101? For those of you unfamiliar with George Orwell's '1984' (which is a book that probably should've been burned long before it gave the world the ironic and iconic phrase "Big Brother is watching you"), Room 101 is the dumping ground for mankind's worst fears and bugbears. In our case we'll twist it a little and make it the place where you'd love to see certain games, peripherals and daft ideas hastily stored away lest they offend the weak and feeble.

First up for dumping: Microsoft's Kinect for Xbox 360

There are many reasons for my ire when it comes to Kinect. Front and centre is the fact that the thing just...doesn't...work...very...well in the majority of cases. It's twitchy, it seems to need constant mollycoddling, calibration and farting around with to get the laggy piece of shit actually doing what its supposed to do - recognising your body movements and interpreting them into some sort of gameplay.

There have been a few high points with the thing. Kinectimals - a game where you control virtual animals - has proved that the technology does work after a fashion if the developers writing for the thing actually get a proper handle on the SDK and second-guess random human movements and turn them into something smooth and predictable. Wrapped around a gorgeous graphics engine, Kinectimals is still very much a showcase title for Kinect.

See also Kinect Sports - again, an extremely good example of what can be done with the technology if the developers give a flying fig about improving the gameplay experience and making something fun and playable that doesn't require a lot of fannying around in order to get everyone joining in and playing.

Lastly on the positive side of things there's Dance Central, a game that is as close to a killer app for Kinect as you're going to get, and a game that sneakily disguises your spasmodic movements as something approaching gameplay. The main reason Dance Central works so well is that the developers thought out the user interface and made it slick, thought out the gameplay elements and made them smooth, and strapped the whole thing around some exquisitely cool dance moves and music.

So now we've dealt with the three reasons to keep Kinect out of Room 101 let's look at the myriad reasons for kicking the thing into the corner of that echoey chamber for good.

First up, Kinect doesn't work as advertised. How could it possibly ever work as advertised? It's far too slow for starters, and even the three games mentioned above are sneaky with the way they mask the terrible lag between what you do and what Kinect interprets you as doing on screen.

Simply put, Kinect just can't watch you, figure out what you're doing, then relay that information back to the Xbox 360 for processing as quickly as a physical controller or button press can. No way, no day - and because of that the device instantly becomes eminently unsuitable for a whole brace of game interactions we take for granted when using a joypad or when using some of the more accurate motion-sensing controllers on the market on other platforms.

Next, there's Kinect's strange minotaur-like lack of processing depth perception. Although the device can tell how close / far you're standing from it, it can't do this quickly enough on the fly to detect an accurate arm swing, foot kick or thrown object without a heck of a lot of smoke and mirror stuff wrapped around your movements. Kinect Sports does an extremely good job of coming up with an approximation of kicks for footie, and arm movements for bowling but very few other games seem to be able to pull off this trick sufficiently well enough to fool you into believing what you just did in the real world is what your on-screen character just did in the game.

Moving on there's the lack of a physical 'action' or 'fire' button. This manifests itself in the simplest possible way when you have to interact with any game menus on kinect titles. You can't click on anything, so you are forced to adopt the old Eyetoy trick of hovering over a menu item to select it.

Now consider if you will a game where firing at a target is the main focus of the gameplay. Gears of War 3 is apparently 'gearing up' for Kinect, and it's nigh on impossible to imagine how they're going to do anything except stream a constant dribble of fire from your machine gun and let you wave your arms around to direct it in some on-rails shooter type effort. Kinect can't do any better. You cannot point at the screen and click your fingers like a virtual gun, and see waves of enemies fall instantly. If Microsoft went back on their promise of making Kinect the controller-free motion sensing solution it currently is, and produced some sort of a wireless 'side arm' for the thing, it could be improved tenfold. 

And so to the last reason why Kinect deserves to be toe-punted into Room 101 at the behest of the Ministry of Game Love - the stubborn bloody-mindedness of Microsoft to force developers to use Kinect THEIR way. Think for a second about the way you play games. Slumped in a comfy chair, beer at your side, tutting girlfriend or wife mumbling about your lack of gaming prowess under her breath while dutifully watching your hapless machinations. You're in a dimly lit (and probably impossibly cluttered) games room with just enough space to swing a joypad. This is not the clean almost sterile sun-lit environment filled with smiling elder relatives and hyperactive toothy children you see in Kinect adverts. This is the reality of gaming. No Kinect game currently caters for gamers who would love to see the device used as a secondary system for, say, detecting arm movements or head tracking. Perhaps even something used as a method to produce user-generated content in games. So far we've been promised much, and have actually seen very little from MS other than a few assurances that 'the best is yet to come' and 'Cambridge science bods have improved Kinect's tracking ability tenfold' without actually seeing anything backing up those claims.

Meanwhile the device is slowly being turned into a dumping ground for a metric ton of fuckawful fitness titles or minigame collections. Sound familiar?

With that I'll carefully package my dust-covered Kinect sensor up in its box, put it on the conveyor belt and press the button to damn it for eternity to Room 101.

Got something game-related you loathe? Write to us, and we'll see if it's ripe for inclusion in this series of ubercynical articles.

 

User Comments:

You must sign up for an AATG account and login in order to post comments

Flying_Pig - on 18/04/2011 at 11:31 wrote:
 
Nice article - seems to pretty much sum up why I have zero interest in Kinect.

What about putting Boss Battles into 101??
 

peej - on 18/04/2011 at 11:50 wrote:
 
I dunno, I rather like some of the boss battles I've encountered in Bulletzone so far.

But definitely up for seeing more like this. Surely someone out there must be as annoyed as I am in seeing developers rigorously insisting that you press the start button at the beginning of a game (when most of us are quite happy to lazily stab away at the A or X button on our respective controllers)
 

TheBoy - on 18/04/2011 at 12:16 wrote:
 
F_P Pretty much took the words right out of my mouth as that's the way I feel too. Even the recent 80 price point failed to raise my enthusiasm for it.
 

peej - on 18/04/2011 at 12:22 wrote:
 
There's bound to be stuff appearing at E3 this year that will completely turn this article on its head but I reckon early Kinect SDK adopters will probably find more interesting uses for the thing than game developers currently are. Pity really, it's got such a massive takeup that it could comfortably be used as an enhancement to pad-based gaming even if it was just something simple like customising your in-game avatar with some kinect-captured stuff.
 

frod - on 18/04/2011 at 14:31 wrote:
 
Kntcie is almost the exact opposite of what I play videogames for. I'm sure people have fun with it, but I think it has about as much place being discussed on traditional videogame sites as DVDs and Sky TV do.
 

evilashchris - on 18/04/2011 at 14:53 wrote:
 
I love my Kinect, it's a hell of a lot of fun and the kids love it. It works perfectly for me, and a few other folk I know, maybe you need to light the room differently? It's like a little bit of magic in the room. In fact the only downside is my wife keeps shouting kinect when she walks through the room when I'm looking about on the dashboard. Evil woman, that.
 

peej - on 18/04/2011 at 14:59 wrote:
 
I've tried all sorts of lighting conditions etc for certain games and the plain fact of the matter is some games (notably Zumba fitness but other third party things too) are lazily written and just. plain. don't. work.

There are things I like about Kinect (I can take or leave the voice-activated stuff) but it falls hopelessly short of what MS promised and it's really going to continue being used as an old douche-rag for third party bucketware
 

peej - on 18/04/2011 at 15:00 wrote:
 
(btw if anyone wants to follow up this article, 3D could be a contender for the next Room 101 incumbent)
 

evilashchris - on 18/04/2011 at 18:02 wrote:
 
Zumba shorts. Make it happen.
 

peej - on 19/04/2011 at 08:44 wrote:
 
(psst it's the Wii version Mrs Peej has got...The kinect version was just utter tummy rubbish)
 

JimJam - on 19/04/2011 at 20:29 wrote:
 
My missus and my daughter love it, I have to say. I have the same misgivings about the lack of secondary controller as most other gamers. And since my brand loyalty has been totally shot by MS's PR Department just not bothering with our questions, I say "fuck 'em".
 


11 comment(s) in total.
        
Jettomero: Hero of the Universe Review (0) (16/10)
We Are the Robots.
Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana review (0) (13/09)
Funtime in the Sunshine
Sniper Elite 4 Review - Xbox One (1) (21/02)
Nutcracker. Sweet!
Mantis Burn Racing Review (1) (14/10)
Rock 'n' Roll
Mount & Blade Warband Review (0) (16/09)
Siege Mentality
Jettomero: Hero of the Universe Review (0) (16/10)
We Are the Robots.
Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana review (0) (13/09)
Funtime in the Sunshine
Sniper Elite 4 Review - Xbox One (1) (21/02)
Nutcracker. Sweet!
Mantis Burn Racing Review (1) (14/10)
Rock 'n' Roll
Mount & Blade Warband Review (0) (16/09)
Siege Mentality
Hearthstone Beta Review - Gather Round (1) (24/02)
Gather Round Blizzard's Latest Cash-Cow
Dream: The Hypersloth Interview - Part 3 (0) (18/11)
Fears before bedtime
Dream: The Hypersloth Interview - Part 2 (2) (17/11)
I can't get no sleep...
Angband Retrospective (4) (25/10)
Learn to fear the letter D.
Why TitanFall is no Call of Duty Killer (5) (18/02)
But it's still bloody marvellous
Gioteck's PS3 Controller Range - Preview (0) (01/08)
Striving for excellence
Havin' a Go: Mass Effect 3 Multiplayer (4) (27/10)
Don't cry wolf just yet...
Shank 2 Set to Kick Your Ass in Early 2012 (0) (26/10)
Not actually a protein. Go on, google it.

 
Looks who's back. Shady's back.
 
GOD - In response to: Sniper Elite 4 Review - Xbox One - 208day(s) ago.
 
Micro Machines was my favourite!
 
ClaytonNotClive - In response to: Mantis Burn Racing Review - 250day(s) ago.
 
i agree chris, the Aliens table makes the others look bad.. because its so goood!! but they arent that bad.. haha! ...
 
neosalad - In response to: Aliens Vs. Pinball Review - 512day(s) ago.
 
I love it. It's the rally game I've been waiting for since Rallisport Challenge 2 (and it's a lot more technical / satisfying than that!) ...
 
peej - In response to: DiRT Rally Review - 562day(s) ago.
 
This looks and sounds AMAZING.
 
evilashchris - In response to: SUPERHOT Review - 603day(s) ago.